‘Did sufferers come dancing?’ – Rajasthan minister’s remarks about kidney failure case spark row | India Information
3 min learnJaipurUp to date: Jun 12, 2026 08:30 PM IST
Rajasthan Well being Minister Gajendra Singh Khinvsar’s remarks about girls identified with kidney failure after childbirth in Bikaner have kicked up a political row within the state, with the Opposition Congress calling the remarks “callous”.
Whereas visiting Bikaner’s Prince Bijay Singh Memorial (PBM) Hospital — the place 5 such girls had been identified this week — the minister mentioned all 5 had been unwell on the time of their admission. The remarks got here days after 5 girls died of post-operative kidney failure following childbirth in Kota, in a case for which the federal government has sought a report.
“Ladies are in a severe state of affairs. Principal sir, please inform me, what’s the foremost situation of pregnant girls. Payal aayin thi ya naachte hue aayin thi,” (They had been already severe after they had been admitted right here. Principal sir, you inform us, how had been the ladies after they had been admitted right here? Had been they already unwell after they got here in, or did they arrive dancing?)
He went on to say: “Healthcare employees save quite a few lives day-after-day, however such efforts typically go unnoticed. We save so many lives, but you don’t point out that. You concentrate on mortality charges. Out of 1,000 sufferers, two would possibly die whereas the remaining get better and go dwelling; you don’t discuss that.”
The remarks had been deemed callous by the Congress. “The Well being Minister’s remark—suggesting that girls in labour ‘come dancing’—shouldn’t be solely the peak of insensitivity but in addition a gross insult to motherhood,” Opposition chief Tikaram Jully mentioned.
He went on to say: “The minister ought to know that what girls in labour want at such a time shouldn’t be taunts about singing and dancing, however relatively secure deliveries and higher healthcare amenities in hospitals”.
“The situation of presidency hospitals within the state has deteriorated to the purpose the place girls in labour are unable to even entry stretchers. The Well being Minister is resorting to such irresponsible rhetoric to masks his personal failures, which is totally shameful. He should instantly apologize to the folks of the state and to girls for this assertion,” mentioned Jully, including that it was “nothing new for BJP leaders to make such shameful and undignified remarks towards girls; such behaviour displays their mental chapter”.
Story continues beneath this advert
On Thursday, Congress employees held protests towards the “degrading medical situations of Rajasthan” and tried to enter the hospital premises. Movies from the protests present police struggling with demonstrators.
5 girls admitted to PBM Authorities Hospital in Bikaner developed extreme issues, together with kidney failure, earlier this week. This comes days after 5 girls died of maternal well being issues following C-section deliveries at a authorities hospital in Kota. The Rajasthan authorities has maintained that the 2 incidents had been unrelated and that the ladies had been admitted below “totally different circumstances”.
The ladies on the Bikaner hospital are acknowledged to be steady.
