‘Possibly it’s your values’: Shri Thanedar slams Republican chief for saying Muslims ‘don’t belong’ in American society

Indian-origin Congressman Shri Thanedar has criticised Republican lawmaker Andy Ogles after the Tennessee consultant wrote on social media that “Muslims do not belong in American society”.The dispute started when Rep. Andy Ogles posted on X: “Muslims do not belong in American society. Pluralism is a lie.”Thanedar, a Democratic congressman from Michigan, responded: “The founders put freedom of faith within the FIRST Modification for a motive. Muslims have lived in America because the 1600s. E Pluribus Unum, an ode to our pluralism, has been our nation’s conventional motto since 1782. Possibly it’s YOUR values that don’t belong in American society.”Thanedar meant that the USA was based on the concept of unity amongst various folks and religions, so rejecting Muslims contradicts the nation’s long-standing precept of pluralism.British journalist Mehdi Hasan additionally criticised Ogles’ remarks on-line. In a put up on X, Hasan wrote: “Jews do not belong in American society.”He added that such an announcement from a member of Congress would usually provoke a nationwide outcry.Hasan mentioned: “Think about a sitting member of Congress tweeting that. You’ll be able to’t. Fortunately, it’d by no means occur. And if it did, it might be the top of their profession and the largest story in America. However Ogles can say this about Muslims with none censure.”Ogles is a Republican politician recognized for strongly conservative positions, notably on immigration and faith. He has proposed laws geared toward limiting immigration from a number of international locations with predominantly Muslim populations and has argued that large-scale Islamic immigration harms the USA.Ogles has additionally supported stricter immigration insurance policies typically. Previously, he has prompt deporting sure immigrants or naturalised residents whom he believes threaten American values.